Perils and Promise of the Shiny New Object

This post is provided by guest blogger, Suzanne Gillespie, graduate student at the University of St. Francis in Joliet, MS in Talent Development program.

Dannewitz’s (2025) TD Magazine article, “All That Glitters Is Not Gold” argues that while emerging learning technologies can feel exciting and futuristic, L&D professionals must resist being dazzled by novelty alone. The article emphasizes distinguishing hype from tools that genuinely improve performance. It encourages practitioners to evaluate technologies based on clear business needs, measurable outcomes, and practical integration into existing workflows. Rather than chasing flashy demos—like AI chatbots or immersive VR—the piece urges focusing on solutions that solve real problems, scale sustainably, and enhance everyday learning experiences. Ultimately, meaningful impact—not trendiness—should guide technology adoption.

TD Magazine, a publication from the Association for Talent Development, is a reputable source within the learning and development field, so the article carries solid credibility, especially for practitioners seeking grounded perspectives on emerging technologies. The article “All That Glitters Is Not Gold” is useful because it challenges readers to look past hype and evaluate tools based on real organizational impact. Its emphasis on strategic decision‑making makes it valuable for L&D leaders, instructional designers, and HR professionals who must justify technology investments. While the article offers practical guidance, it could go further by providing downloadable evaluation frameworks or concrete case studies. Still, it serves as a thoughtful reminder to prioritize substance over novelty.

Reference

Dannewitz, B. (2025, October 31). All that glitters is not gold. TD Magazine. https://www.td.org/content/td-magazine/all-that-glitters-is-not-gold  

Leave a comment